Research on the Impact of Voluntary Auditor Changes in Chinese Listed Companies on Audit Fees

Liuting Huang; Shixin Yang

doi:10.63944/tsc.JFEMR

Authors

Liuting Huang School of Economics and Management, Guangxi Normal University, China Author
Shixin Yang School of Economics and Management, Guangxi Normal University, China Author

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.63944/tsc.JFEMR

Keywords:

Voluntary auditor change; Audit fees; Policy shock

Abstract

This article takes listed companies in China's A-share market that underwent voluntary auditor changes from 2021 to 2024 as the research object, and empirically examines the impact of voluntary auditor changes on corporate audit fees. The research results show that: (1) voluntary auditor changes significantly reduce corporate audit fees, indicating that companies have bargaining advantages in auditor selection and can achieve cost savings by changing auditors; (2) The new regulatory regulations released in 2023 have significantly changed the audit pricing mechanism, so that voluntary changes no longer have a fee reduction effect; (3) When establishing an audit committee for a company, voluntary auditor changes can significantly reduce audit fees; (4) When state-owned enterprises voluntarily change auditors, the cost reduction effect of audit fees is more significant; (5) Voluntary auditor changes have partially mediated the cost reduction effect on audit fees by reducing the proportion of non audit services. This article provides empirical evidence for enterprises to optimize their auditor selection strategies, and also provides insights for regulatory authorities to identify irrational low price competition in the audit market and regulate pricing order.

References

[1] Zhang T, Wu L S. (2010). Auditor Change and Audit Quality: A Theoretical Anal ysis.Auditing Research, (02), 39-46.

[2] Hu Z R. (2014). A Study on the Voluntary Auditor Change Behavior of Listed Companies in China. Communication of Finance and Accounting, (36), 20-24.

[3] Chen L R, Zhou S G. (2010). Analysis of Auditor Change and Auditor Selection. Business Accounting, (22), 76-77.

[4] Zhou F Y. (2012). Auditor Change, Low-balling and Audit Opinion Shopping: An Examination from the Perspective of Audit Fees. The Chinese Certified Public Accountant, (08), 100-106.

[5] Chen J J. (2018). An Empirical Study on Auditor Change and Integrated Audit Fees. The Chinese Certified Public Accountant, (02), 58-63.

[6] Zhu X Q, Liu X M. (2022). Supervisors' Voluntary Resignation and Auditor Change. Accounting Research, (09), 179-192. 218

[7] Huang C H, Duan T T. (2022). "Last-minute Auditor Change" and Audit Opinion Shopping: An Analysis Based on the Timing of Change. Collected Essays on Finance and Economics, (09), 80-90.

[8] Zhang Y, Wang Z, Lei T Q. (2022). Management Shareholding, Auditor Change, and Financial Information Quality. The Chinese Certified Public Accountant, (10), 26-34+3.

[9] Chang J P, Liu X D, Guo S J. (2013). Analysis of Auditor Change Behavior of Listed Companies in 2011. Finance and Accounting Monthly, (08), 95-97.

[10] Simunic D A. (1980). The Pricing of Audit Services: Theory and Evidence. Journal of Accounting Research, 18(1), 161-190.

[11] Wang J S, Yang Y J. (2023). Research on the Impact of Executive Change on Audit Fees. The Chinese Certified Public Accountant, (11), 48-54.

[12] Christopher B, Ulrike S. (2018). The Effects of Mandatory Audit Firm Rotation on Client Importance and Audit Industry Concentration. The Accounting Review, 93(1), 127. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2308/accr-51728

[13] Bertrand M, Mullainathan S. (2003). Pyramids. Journal of the European Economic Association, 1(2-3), 478-483. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1162/154247603322391116

[14] Huang K, Zhang L M. (2010). Regulatory Oversight, Auditor Change, and Prudence of Successor Auditors. Auditing Research, (01), 65-74+64.

[15] Yang J, Wu L H. (2011). Research on Non-standard Audit Opinions and Voluntary Auditor Change. Modern Management Science, (11), 86-87+105.

[16] Wu L N, Wang C F, Lu Z F. ()2013. Business Group Auditor Change and Audit Opinion Shopping. Auditing Research, (01), 70-78.

[17] Xia Y C, Xin Q Q, Tan Y Q. (2024). Auditor Change and the Robustness of Successor Auditors. Auditing Research, (06), 133-146.

[18] Yan H M, Jiang H Y, Zhang X H, Wang Y Y. (2024). Last-minute "Change of General" and Audit Opinion Shopping. The Chinese Certified Public Accountant, (04), 31-37.

[19] Hu G Q, Pi Y C, Sun W X. (2024). The "New Perspective" Effect of Auditor Change: Textual Evidence Based on Key Audit Matters Disclosure. Auditing Rese arch, (01), 41-52.

[20] Li X H, Yang K. (2016). Auditor Change, Abnormal Audit Fees, and Accounting Information Transparency. Journal of Central University of Finance and Economics, (10), 60-69.

[21] Cao Y, Pu W, Zhang X F, Liu J Y. (2016). Marketization Process, Voluntary Auditor Change, and Degree of Income Tax Avoidance. Finance and Accounting Monthly, (11), 84-91.

[22] Tang Z F. (2012). Research on the Issue of Voluntary Auditor Change in Listed Companies in China. Enterprise Guide, (13), 131-132. 219

[23] Wu Q C, Yan Z J. (2019). Mandatory Rotation of Accounting Firms and Audit Fees. Communication of Finance and Accounting, (03), 17-22+62.

[24] Liu P. (2024). The Impact of the Registration-based IPO System Reform on Audit Quality and Audit Fees of IPO Enterprises. Communication of Finance and Accounting, (21), 29-33+48.

[25] Ding C K. (2023). Audit Market Concentration, Corporate Performance, and Audit Fees. Communication of Finance and Accounting, (03), 50-53.

[26] Liu H, Li X T. (2024). Accounting Firm Size and the "Quasi-standard" Disclosure of Accounting Policies in Annual Reports: Empirical Evidence Based on Text Analysis. Auditing and Economy Research, 39(04), 59-70.

[27] Li M X, Zheng S Q. (2024). Does Accounting Firm Tenure Affect Audit Fees? —Research on the Moderating Effect Based on Equity Nature. Communication of Finance and Accounting, (13), 31-36.

[28] Wang Y R, Zhao Y, Zhou Z H, Wu Y H. (2024). Does the Securities Qualificati on Regulation of Accounting Firms Affect Audit Fees? Communication of Finance and Accounting, (23), 29-33.

[29] Zhou K T, Tao X Y, Zhou X H. (2025). Comparability of Accounting Information and Audit Adjustment. Journal of Nanjing Audit University, 22(02), 67-76.

[30] Xiang Z H, Yang X L. (2013). Enterprise Growth, Signal Transmission, Audit Fees, and Auditor Selection. Communication of Finance and Accounting, (18), 21-23.

[31] Simunic D A. (1980). The Pricing of Audit Services: Theory and Evidence. Journal of Accounting Research, 18(1), 161-190. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/2490397

[32] Cai C, Xie L F, Ma K N N. (2015). Executive's Audit Background, Earnings Management, and Abnormal Audit Fees. Accounting Research, (03), 72-78+95.

[33] Huang L. (2021). Research on Influencing Factors of Audit Fees for A-share Listed Companies in China. Farm Economic Management, (06), 50-51.

[34] Al-Harshani M O. (2008). The Pricing of Audit Services: Evidence from Kuwait. Managerial Auditing Journal, 23(7), 685-696. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1108/02686900810890643

[35] Chen D H, Zhou C Q. (2006). The Impact of Self-selection Issues on Audit Fees: Empirical Evidence from Chinese Listed Companies. Journal of Finance and Economics, (03), 44-55.

[36] Chen N. (2019). The Impact of Auditor Change on Audit Fees: Empirical Data from China's A-Share Market. Northern Economy and Trade, (11), 130-133.

[37] Liu X X, Li M H, Lü W. (2012). Accounting Firm Size and Audit Pricing: An Empirical Study Based on the Experience of Local Chinese Firms. Financial The ory and Practice, 33(05), 69-75.

[38] Wang X H, Yang J, Pan Y T. (2023). An Empirical Study on the Relationship between Accounting Firm Size, Industry Expertise, and Audit Fees. Financial Mana 220 gement Research, (05), 98-103.

[39] Han W F, Liu X X. (2019). Does the Content of Modified Audit Opinions Affect Auditor Change and Audit Fees? Auditing and Economy Research, 34(04), 22-32.

[40] Gu X. (2024). The Structure of China's Audit Market: Trends, Current Situation, and Challenges. Financial Forum, (11), 73-76.

[41] André P, Broye G, Pong C, et al. (2016.) Are Joint Audits Associated with Higher Audit Fees? European Accounting Review, 25(2), 245-274.221 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/09638180.2014.998016