The Paradox of Goodwill Measurement and the Impact of M&A Synergy Effects on Goodwill Measurement

Wei Yao; Yating Yang; Haojie  Liao

doi:10.63944/9x5.JFEMR

作者

Wei Yao Guangxi University of Finance and Economics, China 作者
Yating Yang College ofInternational Education, Dhonburi Rajabhat University, Thonburi,Bangkok, Thailand 作者
Haojie Liao Guangxi University of Finance and Economics, China 作者

DOI：

https://doi.org/10.63944/9x5.JFEMR

关键词：

Goodwill Measurement Paradox; M&A Synergy Effects; Principal Component Analysis; Moderated Mediation Model; Institutional Change

摘要

This study aims to elucidate the formation mechanism of the goodwill measurement paradox and assess the impact of M&A synergy effects on goodwill measurement. Drawing upon empirical evidence from case studies, such as the Geely-Volvo acquisition, and broader empirical research on listed companies, the study seeks to offer practical guidance for refining industry-specific goodwill measurement standards within the registration system. Based on the "Institutional Environment-Synergy Effect-Goodwill Measurement" analytical framework, this study selects 528 non-same-control M&A samples of A-share listed companies from 2018 to 2023 as the research objects, and uses principal component analysis and a moderated mediation model to empirically test the impact of operational, financial, and management synergy effects on goodwill measurement, as well as the moderating roles of industry heterogeneity and policy changes. The conclusions are as follows: 1. The current "difference method" in goodwill measurement shows a significant deviation, with non-synergistic premiums accounting for 21.5%, and reaching as high as 34.2% in technology-intensive industries. 2. Operational, financial, and tax synergy effects all have a positive impact on goodwill measurement, with operational synergy being the most significant (coefficient 0.315***), amplifying to 0.471*** in technology-intensive industries. Synergy effects are mainly transmitted through M&A premiums, with the mediating effect of operational synergy accounting for 42.8%. 3. After the policy strengthening in 2019, the correlation between synergy effects and goodwill measurement increased by 12.5%, but technology-intensive industries still have a high impairment rate of 15.2%, indicating that policies have yet to fully eradicate the disparities in measurement risks among industries. 4. This study is the first to quantify the moderating effects of policy changes and industry attributes on goodwill measurement, theoretically unveiling the core of the goodwill measurement paradox, and practically offering crucial guidance for refining relevant regulations, enhancing valuationtion systems, and formulating regulatory policies.

参考文献

[1] FASB. (2023). Accounting Standards Codification Topic 805.

[2] Healy P M, Palepu K G, Ruback R. (1987).The book 'Mergers, Sell-offs, and Economic Efficiency' by Ravenscraft and Scherer, published by the Brookings Institution Press in 1987, has been reviewed and utilized in academic research to study the efficiency implications of mergers in U.S. manufacturing. Ravenscraft DJ, Scherer F M. Mergers, Sell-offs, and Economic Efficiency. Brookings Institution Press.

[3] Shleifer A, Vishny R W. (1997). The takeover wave of the 1980s. Journal of Financial Economics, 49(1):3-19. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1745-6622.1991.tb00615.x

[4] Zhong Han. (2012). Goodwill, residual income and Ohlson model. Finance and Accounting Monthly, (06): 21-24.

[5] Xie Deren. (2024). On the accounting logic dilemma of current M&A goodwill measurement. Finance and Accounting Monthly, (3): 7-10.

[6] Li Mingyang. (2023). Critical reconstruction of goodwill measurement paradigm. Accounting Research, (5): 45-52.

[7] Wang Lihua, Zhang Wei. (2022). Research on goodwill measurement model based on resource-based view. Audit & Economy Research, 37(4): 12-20.

[8] Zhao Min. (2022). Quantitative research on supply chain synergy effect. Management World, (7): 55-63.

[9] Chen Xiaoming. (2024). Application prospect of artificial intelligence in goodwill measurement. China Accounting Review, (2): 88-96.

[10] Li Na. (2024). Performance mechanism of technical synergy effect in semiconductor industry. Science & Technology Progress and Policy, (1): 15-23.

[11] Zhou Tao. (2023). Research on synergy effect bubble of high premium mergers and acquisitions. China Industrial Economics, (5): 67-76.

[12] Zhang Tianyang, Zhao Nahui. (2025). Research on the signal effect of M&A idiosyncratic information disclosure level—Based on text analysis of M&A restructuring reports. Friends of Accounting, (11): 20-28.